The edge is off, or why I love dead games.

AEG has recently announced that Doomtown Reloaded, their LCG-style card game, will be ending its run upon completing the current expansion cycle.  It’s a sad time for all fans of the game. So, why am I overjoyed?

I am a fan of Doomtown, with a collection consisting of two core sets, and all expansions up to date. I love Gomorra with all its lore (in fact, I used to play Deadlands as a teenager), and I vastly enjoy the quirky, somewhat counterintuitive mechanisms of the game. So, once again, why am I happy?

Because the edge is off.


Collectible, customizable, and expandable games have a specific dynamic. The core player base that starts with a healthy mix of those who were drawn by a mix of theme and mechanisms, and those who are there to crunch the numbers, uncover all the secrets, and conquer their opponents, will inevitably shift towards being dominated by the latter group.

When this happens, players who want to stay in the game will have to make regular investments, allocating both funds and (sometimes even more precious) time to being able to follow the meta. For those who are more inclined towards slow exploration of the game and towards enjoying its theme, that pace is usually too high, and the competitive environment becomes even more cutthroat, as they slowly but inevitably leave the game.

Now that Doomtown is about to ride off into the sunset however, its player base will change once again. The most competitive players will walk away, sell their collections and find a new game that is alive, and that provides them with the type of challenge and thrill they seek. Soon, finding a Doomtown game group will become a bit more difficult, but also more satisfying in terms of finding like-minded individuals who are staying more because of their love of the game, and less because of its highly competitive dynamic.

I know your mileage may vary on all of the above. I am now speaking from my own experiences, looking back at my days of being a Warhammer Invasion player, starting out as a fan of the theme, going deep into competitive scene, being on the brink of leaving the game completely, and finally celebrating the day I bought the last expansion. Since then, I was able to explore the game at my own pace, and play it occasionally with people who stayed – people who simply loved the game, and not the thrill of constant competition.

Hidden Kingdoms - the final Warhammer Invasion expansion.
Hidden Kingdoms – the final Warhammer Invasion expansion.

So, if you’re a competitive player, I can only say I’m sorry for your loss, and I wish you well. I am not a part of your tribe, but I really have nothing against you. I just like to play different games. And if you’re someone thinking about coming back, or about taking your first plunge into Gomorra, now is the best time. While it’s not really good news for AEG, the game will live on (like many discontinued card games) among its fans.

Soon you’ll even be able to find some great deals on core sets and expansions, and in a few months, you’ll be able to say that you have a complete playset. And that is something the completionist in me is also celebrating, because… well… because I’m petty that way.


Share on FacebookShare on Google+Tweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedInPin on PinterestDigg thisBuffer this pageShare on RedditShare on VKShare on YummlyShare on TumblrShare on StumbleUponFlattr the authorEmail this to someonePrint this page

3 thoughts on “The edge is off, or why I love dead games.

  1. My heart hurts – I am probably more competitive than you are. But only a bit.
    What I like about this situation is that I will finally be able to sit in front of the WHOLE game and find my way to get the best deck without it getting old in a few weeks.

  2. Well, according to new rumors, there is life still in this game despite AEG’s tries to kill it off 🙂
    We will know alot more after all the expansions have been released – some form of statement will come. And if the rumors are true, we players will be very happy 🙂

    I agree though – a ‘dead’ game can be very nice to play since it is
    ‘complete’. Although, it can also make for a very strange meta, with just a few viable choices.

Leave a Reply